HomeAbout Us
Beauty & Personal Care
The 9 Best Oil Free Eyeliners [Including 1 to Avoid]
B. B. Lykert
B. B. Lykert
July 08, 2023
PreviewBrandMy RatingPrice
GenericGeneric9.4/10Check Price Now
REVLONREVLON9.2/10Check Price Now
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUPNYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP9.2/10Check Price Now
RimmelRimmel9.2/10Check Price Now
AlmayAlmay9.0/10Check Price Now
AlmayAlmay9.0/10Check Price Now
stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner ORIGINAL Intense Blackstila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner ORIGINAL Intense Black9.0/10Check Price Now
AlmayAlmay9.0/10Check Price Now
MAYBELLINEMAYBELLINE9.0/10Check Price Now
LAshXLAshX1/10Check Price Now

Generic Oil Free Eyeliner

Generic Oil Free Eyeliner

It glides on easily with the felt tip applicator, and it doesn’t tug or pull at the delicate skin around my eyes. The formula is very pigmented and long-lasting - it lasted all day without smudging or fading. The only downside to this eyeliner is that it can be slightly difficult to remove. I had to use a stronger make-up remover than usual to get it off completely in one go.

In conclusion, I’m really pleased with the Generic oil free eyeliner, and would definitely recommend it to those looking for a long lasting, easy to apply and remove product. The colour range is great, too - there are plenty of shades to choose from!

Be sure to also check out these glitter mascaras that I also compared! Plus, here is the price history on Amazon:

Price history for Generic Oil Free Eyeliner on Amazon

Check Price on Amazon

REVLON

REVLON

The eyeliner glides on smoothly with hardly any pressure needed. The formula does not smudge, which is great for all-day wear without the need to touch up. It also has a nice semi-matte finish that doesn’t look too shiny.

The color payoff is also amazing. It’s an intense black and it lasts a long time. Even after several hours, the color still looks vibrant and hasn’t faded away at all like some other brands I’ve purchased before this one.

I also love that this product is oil free, so my eyes don’t get irritated or red due to ingredients that could potentially hurt the delicate skin around my eyes.

The only downside I found was that it dried out quickly when it wasn’t properly closed after use, which meant I had to sharpen it more often than I’d like. But overall, REVLON oil free eyeliner seems to be an excellent eyeliner considering the affordable price and great quality of the product itself!

Be sure to also check out these inner corner highlights that I also compared! Plus, here is the price history on Amazon:

Price history for REVLON  on Amazon


NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Oil Free Eyeliner

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Oil Free Eyeliner

The eyeliner is easy to apply and doesn’t smudge, no matter how long it’s on. The color is true-to-life, with a variety of colors to choose from, including a deep black that makes your eyes really stand out. It also lasts through rain and sweat without smearing or fading.

The one drawback I found was that it doesn’t come with a sharpener so you’ll need to buy one separately if you don’t already own one.

Overall, I’m really happy with the product and would definitely recommend it to others who are looking for a reliable, inexpensive eyeliner. It applies nice and smooth and has a wide range of colors to choose from. Plus, it stays put through any activity - even swimming!

Be sure to also check out these eyebrow stamp kits that I also compared! Plus, here is the price history on Amazon:

Price history for NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Oil Free Eyeliner on Amazon


Rimmel

Rimmel

The product itself is of high quality and made with premium materials. It’s waterproof, smudge-proof and comes in black, brown and charcoal. The eyeliner pencil is easy to apply and has a soft tip. It goes on smoothly, without tugging or pulling at the skin, plus it blends nicely into other makeup products.

I love the fact that this product is oil free as I have sensitive skin and it can often react badly to heavy oils found in some eye makeup. This liner stays put all day long, even after a few hours of wear it still looks fresh and natural - no flaking or fading!

Overall I am really pleased with Rimmel oil free eyeliner - it’s gentle on my eyes but also highly effective in making them look beautiful! I would definitely recommend this to anyone looking for an affordable eyeliner that won’t irritate their skin.

Be sure to also check out these hypoallergenic eyeshadows that I also compared! Plus, here is the price history on Amazon:

Price history for Rimmel  on Amazon


Almay Oil Free Eyeliner

Almay Oil Free Eyeliner

I’m so impressed with this product! It has a smooth, creamy texture that glides on easily and precisely. The color payoff is amazing; it’s a deep black that lasts all day long without smudging or fading. Even if my eyes tear up, this eyeliner doesn’t transfer or start to run. Best of all, it’s completely oil free so I can trust that it won’t clog my pores or cause any breakouts.

I’m also surprised by how affordable Almay’s eyeliner is. For just what I paid, I think this is one of the best values out there. Plus the packaging comes in a retractable container which makes it really handy for makeup touch-ups during the day.

I highly recommend Almay Oil Free Eyeliner for anyone looking for an affordable yet high quality product that is smooth and easy to apply with great color payoff and staying power.

Be sure to also check out these brunette beauties that I also compared! Plus, here is the price history on Amazon:

Price history for Almay Oil Free Eyeliner on Amazon


Almay

Almay

I love the convenience of this product - it’s so easy to apply, and it goes on nice and evenly. It also lasts a long time - I can easily wear it throughout the day without having to reapply. The color looks great, too - it’s a deep black that really stands out against my skin tone.

The only downside is that it doesn’t have the most precise tip. So if you’re looking for an eyeliner with a super thin line, this isn’t the best option. But overall, I’m very pleased with this purchase! It’s affordable, it stays on forever, and it looks great - what more could I ask for?

Be sure to also check out these llba lashes that I also compared! Plus, here is the price history on Amazon:

Price history for Almay  on Amazon


stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner ORIGINAL Intense Black

stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner ORIGINAL Intense Black

After using it for a few weeks, I discovered that it glides on easily and creates a long-lasting, intense line. It looks smudge-proof and doesn’t flake off near the eye corner like some other products do. The color is also very saturated, which I really enjoy.

The eyeliner is so easy to use that even a beginner can make precise lines with it. Plus, the triangle tip helps you create sharp lines with just one swipe. It also has been proven to be water resistant without compromising its smooth application – so no matter how many times your eyes tear up or water when you’re out in the sun, your eyeliner will stay put.

Overall, I’m very pleased with this product and would recommend it to anyone who wants a reliable eyeliner that is comfortable to apply and gives you consistent results every time.

Be sure to also check out these elf primers that I also compared! Plus, here is the price history on Amazon:

Price history for stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner ORIGINAL Intense Black on Amazon


Almay

Almay

As a contact-wearer who has sensitive eyes that often water, I was looking for an eyeliner that wouldn’t smudge, run or cause irritation. Almay oil free eyeliner checked all of those boxes and more!

It is incredibly easy to use, with a smooth applicator tip that glides on easily without skidding or skipping. The black color is oh-so-pigmented and long lasting while still being lightweight and comfortable enough to wear all day. Plus, the waterproof formula really works - even during allergy season when my eyes would normally be running.

The only minor downside I’d mention is that it takes a few seconds longer than other liners to dry after application. But overall this product is definitely worth the price tag - I’m no longer worried about my eyeliner fading away or transferring onto my contacts throughout the day.

Be sure to also check out these winnie the pooh party favors that I also compared! Plus, here is the price history on Amazon:

Price history for Almay  on Amazon


MAYBELLINE Oil Free Eyeliner

MAYBELLINE Oil Free Eyeliner

Highlights
Doesn’t run
Easy to apply
Long-lasting
Easily removable

When it comes to oil free eyeliners, the MAYBELLINE brand certainly knows how to deliver a stellar performance. This eyeliner doesn’t just promise a flawless application; it actually delivers on that promise.

One of the highlights of this product is its exceptional staying power. Once applied, it stays put throughout the day without any smudging or fading. Whether you’re facing a hectic day at work or dancing the night away, you can trust that your eyeliner will remain intact.

What sets this oil free eyeliner apart from others is its ability to withstand even the oiliest of skin types. No matter how slick your skin gets, this eyeliner doesn’t budge. It’s like having a loyal friend who never lets you down, even in the stickiest situations.

Applying this eyeliner is an absolute breeze. Its smooth and creamy formula glides effortlessly across your lash line, allowing for precise and defined strokes. You don’t have to worry about any tugging or pulling on your delicate eye area.

Another fantastic feature of this product is its easy removal. With just a swipe of makeup remover or micellar water, it effortlessly dissolves away without leaving behind any residue.

In conclusion, if you’re searching for an oil free eyeliner that truly lives up to its claims, look no further than MAYBELLINE brand. Its long-lasting formula, easy application, and effortless removal make it a clear winner in my book. Say goodbye to raccoon eyes and hello to smudge-free perfection!

Be sure to also check out these nude blushes that I also compared! Plus, here is the price history on Amazon:

Price history for MAYBELLINE Oil Free Eyeliner on Amazon


LAshX

LAshX

The color payoff is great, the black is super dark and I like how it’s buildable. The packaging is also very nice, with a sleek design.

Unfortunately, this eyeliner smudges easily, making it difficult to create a perfect cat eye look. It also dried out quickly as well. After having it in my make-up bag for less than two weeks, my eyeliner was almost completely dried out and unusable. Additionally, I think the price is way too high for such a low quality product.

In conclusion, LAshX oil free eyeliner is not worth the money. It’s a shame because the color payoff and packaging are great but the smudging and drying up quickly are deal breakers for me.

Here is the price history on Amazon:

Price history for LAshX  on Amazon


B. B. Lykert

B. B. Lykert

Chief of Reviews

I've always had a knack for reviewing products ever since I was a child - heck - I still kind of am a kid (at heart).

Expertise

Deal Finding
Product Reviewing

Other Posts

Our Favorite 9 Best Hydrocolloid Bandages [With 1 to Avoid]
The packaging is minimalistic yet attractive, and the product inside is equally as good. I was looking for a vegan-friendly and not-tested-on-animals...
B. B. Lykert
August 02, 2023
Review Rune was founded to help you analyze and compare products from every perspective. Deep dive reviews & comparisons along with insights from experts and professionals. For more information, check out our About Us page
© 2023, All Rights Reserved.

Quick Links

About UsContact Us