HomeAbout Us
Beauty & Personal Care
Our Favorite 9 Best Hypoallergenic Eyeshadows [With 1 to Avoid]
B. B. Lykert
B. B. Lykert
July 05, 2023
PreviewBrandMy RatingPrice
Honest BeautyHonest Beauty9.2/10Check Price Now
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUPNYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP9.2/10Check Price Now
Physicians FormulaPhysicians Formula9.0/10Check Price Now
Physicians FormulaPhysicians Formula9.0/10Check Price Now
COVERGIRLCOVERGIRL9.0/10Check Price Now
AlmayAlmay8.8/10Check Price Now
Physicians FormulaPhysicians Formula8.8/10Check Price Now
Physicians FormulaPhysicians Formula8.8/10Check Price Now
AlmayAlmay8.8/10Check Price Now
LOKFARLOKFAR1/10Check Price Now

Honest Beauty Hypoallergenic Eyeshadow

Honest Beauty Hypoallergenic Eyeshadow

The eyeshadow comes in a small, pocket-sized container with 12 colors ranging from light to dark. It’s highly pigmented and goes on smoothly. The product also blended nicely and didn’t leave me with any telltale creases or smudges. What really impressed me though was that it was hypoallergenic so I didn’t have to worry about any skin issues after applying it. It lasted all day without having to add more throughout the day and was great for those late nights out.

In terms of quality, I think the price reflects it accurately. The colors are vibrant and true to their description. They also stayed in place all day which is not always an easy feat!

Overall, Honest Beauty Hypoallergenic Eyeshadow is definitely worth the price tag for its quality and staying power! It’s perfect for anyone who has sensitive skin or just wants a long lasting eyeshadow look that won’t wear off quickly.

Be sure to also check out these inner corner highlights that I also compared! Plus, here is the price history on Amazon:

Price history for Honest Beauty Hypoallergenic Eyeshadow on Amazon

Check Price on Amazon

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP

It arrived faster than expected, which I really appreciated.

The eyeshadow comes in a sleek rectangular packaging with 12 different colors ranging from soft pastels like baby pink, mauve and nude to bolder hues like royal blue and purple. As soon as I swiped on the eyeshadow, I was impressed with its buttery texture – it melted into my skin and blended effortlessly.

As someone who has sensitive skin around my eyes, it was so refreshing to find an eyeshadow that didn’t irritate them or cause me any discomfort. There was no irritation when I used the product and even after wearing it for hours, my eyelids still felt comfortable - no redness or itching whatsoever! Plus, the long-lasting formula kept my eye makeup looking vibrant all day long.

I’m very happy with this purchase and highly recommend NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP hypoallergenic eyeshadow to anyone looking for a high quality product that won’t irritate their skin!

Be sure to also check out these glitter mascaras that I also compared! Plus, here is the price history on Amazon:

Price history for NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP  on Amazon


Physicians Formula Hypoallergenic Eyeshadow

Physicians Formula Hypoallergenic Eyeshadow

On the positive side, the color range is great - I can mix and match different shades to create bold or soft looks. The eyeshadow itself is very soft and creamy, making it easy to blend. It’s also long-lasting, meaning I can leave my makeup on all day without worrying about it fading away.

But what sets this product apart is that it’s hypoallergenic; even though I’m prone to allergies, I haven’t had any reactions when wearing this eyeshadow! Moreover, its formula contains natural ingredients like Vitamin E and jojoba oil, which nourish and protect the delicate skin around my eyes.

In conclusion, Physicians Formula hypoallergenic eyeshadow offers a wide range of colors and shades that are easy to blend and last all day. The fact that it’s hypoallergenic and full of natural ingredients make it even better!

Be sure to also check out these eyebrow stamp kits that I also compared! Plus, here is the price history on Amazon:

Price history for Physicians Formula Hypoallergenic Eyeshadow on Amazon


Physicians Formula

Physicians Formula

The application was really easy and the shadows felt really smooth on my eyelids. I could also mix them to get different colors, which was a nice touch. The color selection was great too; they had every shade I wanted.

The staying power was excellent; the eyeshadow didn’t start fading until around 9 hours after application. It also felt light on my skin and it didn’t irritate my eyes, which is great since I have sensitive skin.

I do wish it came with a brush though, as that would make it much easier to apply the eyeshadow. Another downside is that it’s quite expensive for an eyeshadow palette, but considering its quality and hypoallergenic ingredients, I think it’s worth the price.

Overall, I’m very satisfied with Physicians Formula hypoallergenic eyeshadow, and I’d definitely recommend it to anyone looking for a good-quality product.

Be sure to also check out these oil free eyeliners that I also compared! Plus, here is the price history on Amazon:

Price history for Physicians Formula  on Amazon


COVERGIRL Hypoallergenic Eyeshadow

COVERGIRL Hypoallergenic Eyeshadow

After trying it out for the first time, I was pleasantly surprised. The eyeshadow is highly pigmented and extremely easy to apply. The colors are vivid and stay put all day without any creasing or fading. It also blends really well with other shadows, giving a natural finish.

The best thing about this product is that it’s hypoallergenic, which means I can use it without worrying about any irritation or breakouts on my sensitive skin. The packaging itself isn’t particularly fancy, but it’s sturdy and convenient enough to carry around in your purse if needed.

I haven’t experienced any type of negative effects after using this product so far, and all in all I’m very pleased with my purchase. COVERGIRL hypoallergenic eyeshadow offers good color payoff, long-lasting wear and gentle formula - what more could you ask for? Highly recommended!

Be sure to also check out these brunette beauties that I also compared! Plus, here is the price history on Amazon:

Price history for COVERGIRL Hypoallergenic Eyeshadow on Amazon


Almay

Almay

It definitely lives up to the hypoallergenic claim - I have sensitive skin and often break out in a rash after using eyeshadow, but this Almay formula has caused no such problem. The consistency was really nice - quite creamy, which made it easy to blend out. The colour payoff is good - one swipe over my eyelid gives me strong pigmentation that lasts throughout the day without fading or smudging.

I only have two minor complaints about this product. Firstly, it does contain talc, so there was a bit of fallout upon application. Secondly, I do find that I need to touch up my eyeshadow mid-day if I don’t use an eyelid primer first, although this isn’t necessarily a fault of the eyeshadow itself. All in all, I’m very pleased with my purchase of Almay Hypoallergenic Eyeshadow and would recommend it to anyone else with sensitive skin looking for a dependable eyeshadow product!

Be sure to also check out these llba lashes that I also compared! Plus, here is the price history on Amazon:

Price history for Almay  on Amazon


Physicians Formula Hypoallergenic Eyeshadow

Physicians Formula Hypoallergenic Eyeshadow

The eyeshadow is velvety soft and incredibly pigmented. I was amazed at how much color I could get with just a single swipe of the brush. The color lasted all day too - no creasing or fading!

The eyeshadow also has a pleasant, subtle scent and applies easily without feeling heavy or sticky. Once applied, it did not irritate my sensitive skin at all, which was great knowing that it is hypoallergenic.

The only downside is that even using a light touch, there can be a bit of an uneven application with some shades due to their high intensity. That being said, overall I would highly recommend Physicians Formula hypoallergenic eyeshadow for anyone who needs a safe and reliable product that won’t irritate skin or fade through the day.

Be sure to also check out these elf primers that I also compared! Plus, here is the price history on Amazon:

Price history for Physicians Formula Hypoallergenic Eyeshadow on Amazon


Physicians Formula

Physicians Formula

The eyeshadow is incredibly easy to apply - the pigment goes on smoothly and evenly. I have very sensitive skin, and I found that it didn’t irritate my eyes at all. It also lasts for a decent amount of time - no need for touch-ups through the day.

The range of colors Physicians Formula offers was really impressive; there were so many shades to choose from! As an added bonus, it was also paraben free, and I felt great knowing that none of the ingredients would harm my skin.

The only downside I can think of is that the brush included doesn’t pick up a lot of product, which means you need to keep dipping into the palette. This can be a bit annoying, but overall this eyeshadow is well worth the money in terms of quality and convenience.

Be sure to also check out these winnie the pooh party favors that I also compared! Plus, here is the price history on Amazon:

Price history for Physicians Formula  on Amazon


Almay Hypoallergenic Eyeshadow

Almay Hypoallergenic Eyeshadow

Highlights
No irritation or tiredness
Great for everyday use
Affordable price

When it comes to finding a hypoallergenic eyeshadow that won’t leave my eyes irritated or feeling tired, Almay has truly come through for me. From the moment I applied this product, I could feel the difference compared to other brands.

One of the highlights of Almay’s hypoallergenic eyeshadow is its ability to keep my sensitive eyes happy and healthy. No irritation, no redness, just pure comfort all day long. It’s like a spa treatment for my eyelids!

What I love most about this eyeshadow is its versatility. The colors are perfect for everyday use, whether you’re going for a natural look or something more bold and glamorous. The pigmentation is fantastic, allowing you to build up the intensity as desired without looking cakey.

Not only does Almay deliver on performance, but it also won’t break your bank. With an affordable price tag, you can enjoy high-quality eyeshadow without emptying your wallet.

In conclusion, if you’re in search of a hypoallergenic eyeshadow that delivers on both comfort and style, look no further than Almay. Its gentle formula will keep your eyes happy while providing beautiful color payoff. Say goodbye to irritation and hello to fabulous eye looks!

Be sure to also check out these nude blushes that I also compared! Plus, here is the price history on Amazon:

Price history for Almay Hypoallergenic Eyeshadow on Amazon


LOKFAR Hypoallergenic Eyeshadow

LOKFAR Hypoallergenic Eyeshadow

The color blend and pigmentation of this eyeshadow is terrible. I got the matte purple color, and when I applied it to my eyelids, they looked almost gray. When I tried to apply it more heavily to get the purple shade that I wanted, it all clumped together in an unflattering way. The product also left a greasy feeling on my skin after applying it, which was not pleasant.

However, one positive aspect of the product was definitely the fact that it was hypoallergenic. Even though my allergies are mild, I still felt confident wearing LOKFAR hypoallergenic eyeshadow without fear of my eyes having a reaction.

All in all, although this product might work for some people with very mild skin allergies, I would not recommend using LOKFAR hypoallergenic eyeshadow for makeup purposes. The poor quality of the pigment and texture make this product too difficult to work with for beautiful results.

Here is the price history on Amazon:

Price history for LOKFAR Hypoallergenic Eyeshadow on Amazon


B. B. Lykert

B. B. Lykert

Chief of Reviews

I've always had a knack for reviewing products ever since I was a child - heck - I still kind of am a kid (at heart).

Expertise

Deal Finding
Product Reviewing

Other Posts

Our Favorite 9 Best Hydrocolloid Bandages [With 1 to Avoid]
The packaging is minimalistic yet attractive, and the product inside is equally as good. I was looking for a vegan-friendly and not-tested-on-animals...
B. B. Lykert
August 02, 2023
Review Rune was founded to help you analyze and compare products from every perspective. Deep dive reviews & comparisons along with insights from experts and professionals. For more information, check out our About Us page
© 2023, All Rights Reserved.

Quick Links

About UsContact Us